Why Is Behaviour Change So Hard?


Understanding the Gap Between Knowing and Doing - Australia’s 5-Star Rated Life & Leadership Coach Insights


There is a podcast I have probably sent to more coaching clients than any other. It is Professor Steve Peters on The Diary of a CEO, talking about his Chimp Model (from the book The Chimp Paradox) and why perfectly rational, intelligent people can behave in ways that make absolutely no sense to them afterwards.

I was reminded of its impact again recently when a new coaching client listened to it and described it as a “light-bulb moment”. The way Peters explained what can happen to our behaviour when emotion takes over had helped him understand some of his own reactions differently.

That comment stayed with me because it gets to the heart of something I see constantly in life coaching and behaviour change work: we can know exactly how we want to behave, genuinely intend to do the right thing, and still find ourselves doing the complete opposite when the moment arrives.

This is not really a knowledge problem.

Most people already know quite a lot about what they should be doing. You know that losing your temper probably will not improve the conversation with your partner. You know going to bed earlier would help if you are permanently exhausted. You know another hour scrolling on your phone is unlikely to make you feel better about the day. You probably know that exercise, eating reasonably well, saving money, setting boundaries and having difficult conversations are generally good ideas.

Yet knowing all of that does not guarantee we will do any of it.

That gap between knowing and doing is where behaviour change gets interesting.

Why Knowing What to Do Is Not Enough to Change Behaviour

There is a decent amount of research behind this gap between intention and action. Research into physical activity, for example, has found that our intentions account for only around 23–28% of the differences in what people actually go on to do. Wanting to make a change matters, but intention alone is nowhere near enough.

The same issue appears when we talk about habits. Phillippa Lally's well-known research found that it took participants an average of about 66 days for a new behaviour to become automatic, but the range was enormous: from 18 days to 254. Lally herself has since cautioned against turning that average into another magic number, because the more important finding was how much habit formation varied between people and behaviours.

So much for “21 days and you've changed your life”.

I think this matters because people regularly interpret difficulty changing as some sort of personal failure. They decide they lack motivation or discipline when the reality is considerably more complicated. Human behaviour is influenced by emotion, environment, previous experiences, beliefs, automatic responses and what the behaviour itself might be doing for us.

Which brings me back to Steve Peters.

The Chimp Model: A Simple Way to Understand Your Behaviour

Peters describes three systems using the language of the Human, the Chimp and the Computer.

The Human represents our rational and considered thinking. It is capable of looking at evidence, thinking ahead and deciding how we would ideally like to respond.

The Chimp is faster, emotional and reactive. It responds strongly to things such as threat, uncertainty, rejection, status and what is happening right now rather than necessarily what will matter tomorrow.

The Computer represents learned beliefs, experiences and automatic patterns that can influence how we respond without requiring much conscious thought.

Clearly, the human brain is considerably more complicated than three neat categories. That is not really why I share the model with people. Its usefulness is that it gives us a language for understanding our behaviour and, importantly, creates some distance between who we are and everything our mind happens to produce.

That distinction can be incredibly useful when you are trying to change.

Your Behaviour Is Not Automatically Your Identity

People are incredibly quick to turn repeated behaviours into descriptions of themselves.

“I’m lazy.”

“I have no willpower.”

“I’m terrible with confrontation.”

“I’ve never been confident.”

“I’m impatient.”

“I’m just an anxious person.”

The problem with these statements is that they start sounding permanent. Once you decide a behaviour or reaction is simply who you are, there is not much room left to question it.

A more useful approach is to become curious about whether you have repeated a particular response often enough that you have started treating it as evidence of your identity.

Perhaps you avoid conflict because you learned very early that keeping everybody happy felt safer.

Perhaps you procrastinate because not starting protects you from finding out whether you might fail.

Perhaps you reach for your phone whenever you feel bored, uncomfortable or lonely because it provides instant distraction.

Perhaps you work constantly because achievement has become connected to how you measure your worth.

That is very different from saying, “This is just who I am.”

Who Do You Actually Want to Be?

One part of Peters' conversation that has always stayed with me is his focus on identifying who you genuinely want to be.

Not what you want to own. Not your job title, income or achievements. Strip those things away for a moment and think about the qualities you would actually like to bring into your life and relationships.

Peters puts it simply: “It’s very important to recognise who you are before we start.”

I like that because many conversations about personal change begin with everything someone needs to stop doing. Stop procrastinating. Stop drinking. Stop overthinking. Stop reacting. Stop eating badly.

Peters starts somewhere else: who are you actually trying to be?

When I explore this with people, the answers tend to sound more like calm, courageous, honest, compassionate, dependable, disciplined, patient or present.

Most of us already have a reasonably clear idea of that person.

The problem is that life has a habit of testing the intention.

It is considerably easier to describe yourself as patient when nobody is annoying you. Being calm sounds wonderful until someone says something that hits a nerve. You can value health and still want the takeaway after a terrible day. You can value your relationship and still become defensive when your partner raises something you do not want to hear.

None of that necessarily means your values are fake. It means there is a gap between what matters to you and the behaviour that sometimes appears under pressure.

That gap is where the work is.

Why Understanding the Root Cause of Behaviour Matters

This is where I think some advice about changing habits becomes too simplistic.

We love neat formulas. Get up at 5am. Habit stack. Download the app. Create the morning routine. Buy another journal. Repeat something for a magical number of days and apparently a new human eventually appears.

Sometimes a simple routine really is all that is required.

Other times the behaviour you are trying to change is doing something useful for you, even if the longer-term consequences are not useful at all.

Food can provide comfort. Alcohol can help someone temporarily switch off. Avoidance can remove anxiety in the short term. Overworking can provide validation. People-pleasing can protect against rejection. Staying in a relationship, job or situation that makes you miserable can still provide the comfort of certainty.

If you only attack the visible behaviour without understanding what keeps reinforcing it, you may find yourself having the same battle repeatedly.

The root cause matters because when we begin to understand what is actually driving a behaviour, we have a much better chance of changing it.

Curiosity Before Judgement

When someone I coach repeats a behaviour they said they wanted to change, lecturing them about it is generally pointless. They already know what happened.

I am much more interested in what happened around it.

What were you feeling? What were you thinking? What happened immediately beforehand? What were you trying to avoid? What did the behaviour give you at that particular moment? When else does this pattern appear?

Those questions do not remove responsibility. Understanding why you snapped at someone does not make the behaviour acceptable, and understanding why you keep avoiding something does not mean you should continue avoiding it.

If anything, awareness increases responsibility because now you have something to work with.

There is a big difference between “I keep doing this because this is who I am” and “I can see the pattern that keeps producing this behaviour.”

One sounds permanent. The other gives you somewhere to begin.

Lasting Behaviour Change Requires Practice

There is one final trap here. Understanding yourself can become another form of procrastination if nothing changes afterwards.

You can know your triggers, understand your childhood, recognise every pattern and explain exactly why you behave the way you do, but if you repeatedly respond in exactly the same way, your life does not change very much.

At some point, a different behaviour has to be practised. You become more patient by recognising the moment you normally react and attempting another response. Confidence grows through repeatedly moving towards situations where you previously pulled away. Discipline develops through keeping enough commitments to yourself that you begin creating evidence that you can rely on yourself.

This is why motivation has never particularly interested me as the foundation for lasting behaviour change. Motivation can be useful, but it comes and goes depending on sleep, stress, mood and whatever else life throws at us.

What changes us over time is repeated evidence.

That is also why meaningful personal change can feel frustratingly slow. Much of it happens in ordinary moments that nobody sees: putting the phone down when you want another hit of distraction, pausing before sending the message, going for the walk when you would rather stay on the couch, having the conversation you have been avoiding, admitting you were wrong or simply noticing an old pattern early enough to choose something different.

None of those moments looks particularly transformational. Repeated often enough, they become exactly that.

So if there is a behaviour in your life that keeps turning up and you know it is not helping you, resist the temptation to immediately make it a statement about who you are.

Look at the behaviour properly. Understand when it happens, what triggers it and what it might be doing for you. Then ask what the person you genuinely want to be would do differently in that same moment.

And practise that response.

You will not get it right every time. Nobody does. But with awareness, repetition and enough opportunities to respond differently, the old behaviour no longer has to automatically get the final say.


Book your free 30-minute exploratory call with me today and begin to understand why you do the things you do and how to make intentional change to your life.


About Luke Fenwick

Luke Fenwick is a Melbourne-based life coach, leadership coach, behaviour strategist and founder of Dawn of Legacy. He works with professionals, leaders and high performers who are ready to build discipline, reshape behaviour and create meaningful personal and professional change. His coaching approach is direct, practical and grounded in the belief that lasting transformation is built through identity, structure, accountability and consistent action.

Next
Next

Are Your Goals Worth Pursuing?